Right Size Me: The Shrinking of Detroit

If what was once the most prosperous manufacturing city in the nation has been brought to its knees, what does that say about our recent past? And if it can't find a way to get up, what does that say about our future? - Daniel Okrent, Time Magazine Columnist

If you were able to rebuild a major metropolitan city from scratch, how would you do it? Just across the river from Windsor, Ontario lies a city where this question has moved from the hypothetical to reality. With brownfield sites and abandoned neighbourhoods becoming the norm, the residents of Detroit, Michigan are seriously asking this question.

As Windsor suffers what all auto industry havens have felt for the past year, their suffering pales in comparison to their American counterpart across the border. In 2010, Detroit will have a population of less than 800,000 people. That’s less than half of the 2 million people that used to thrive in the city back in the 1950s, falling from the 4th to the 11th largest city in America. The situation in Detroit is well documented, but the stats are still staggering to hear: close to 100,000 foreclosed homes (30% of the city’s total homes), median home prices plummeting from $59,700 in 2005 to $8,000 in 2009, 28.9% unemployed – for context, Katrina-ravaged New Orleans had an 11% unemployment rate immediately following the hurricane. Instead of the future city it strived to be for many years, showcasing technologies and new manufacturing wonders of tomorrow, Detroit is now more akin to a frontier town of the old west where lawman can’t contain the crime, where 7 of 9 council members have permits to carry concealed weapons, and where tumbleweeds blow across abandoned burnt-out neighbourhoods. So how does Detroit maintain essential services like garbage pickup, sewer maintenance, and police and fire coverage when the tax and population base has been declining by 1,200 people a month for the last decade yet the physical area covered remains essentially the same?

It can’t.

Already a sprawling city at 2 million people with one of the highest rates of home-ownership in the US back in the 1950s, 800,000 people now use the same sized land, roads, and infrastructure. One third of the 140 square miles of land area is vacant – over 40 square miles, nearly twice the size of Manhattan. In fact, Detroit’s total land area could potentially house 8 million residents. Part of newly elected Detroit Mayor David Bing’s turnaround strategy is to sharply reduce the government to proportionately match the city’s shrinking tax and population base. But others are calling for more drastic measures.

Right Size Me: The Shrinking of Detroit is a one hour documentary for broadcast discussing the potential reduction in physical size of a once great city – or as some locals are saying: Right-Sizing Detroit. The film will explore the choice Detroit faces and its ramifications as well as the potential for re-imagining and re-engineering a city for the future.

Shrinking Detroit

How does one actually accomplish reducing the footprint of a city like Detroit? What is involved? And at what cost? To understand the complexities Right Size Me will examine the idea of whole neighbourhoods being uprooted/flattened/transplanted and how to best redeploy essential city services. We’ll look at the use of eminent domain as a tool and its potential consequences and see how former Eastern Bloc countries right-sized their cities after communism fell. But even with these basic elements examined, how is one able to split the delicate fabric of racially charged tight-knit communities, decide who gets what new home, and develop a plan for the orphan businesses left behind? Residents are already taking various steps to prevent vacant properties from becoming magnets for criminals by mowing lawns, installing curtains and even baby monitors. How will the city manage crime in vacant neighbourhoods?

Future City

Detroit has often been a barometer for the socioeconomic status of America. It ushered in the Industrial age with Ford’s assembly line in the early 20th Century, fulfilled the middle-class dream in the 1950’s, was the focal point for the ugliest racial altercations in the 1960’s, continually redefined American music, and has now become the icon of manufacturing decline. As all eyes focus in on the city, Right Size Me will examine what’s next for Motown. With almost a blank slate to start from, the possibilities are almost endless. Many suggest using the abandoned tracts of land to transform the city from a smog-filled manufacturing center to a green future city, once again paving a path for American cities to follow. Turning portions of land over to nature, creating preserves and parks and leasing other portions to urban farms to grow fresh, affordable food - these are just a few notions of how to better use the land. Already Hantz Farms is looking to set up the World’s Largest Urban Farm. And as various stakeholders debate the merits of a Green Detroit, new culture has infused the city as artists and entrepreneurs begin to see Detroit as a place where they can be true to their vision. Although fueled by lower costs of living, in Motown, you can be the expert or authority on a topic, open a business about it and not have to compromise as much as one might in New York City or Los Angeles.

For Detroit, the risk has never been higher. But the potential rewards have never been greater. And all watch on, eager to dump further on the Motor City should things get worse, or jump on the bandwagon should this weary city get back on its feet.

The Approach

Right Size Me: The Shrinking of Detroit is a one hour documentary for broadcast with a sobering yet hopeful view of a once great city. Using photos, footage, artists’ renderings and maps we will show Detroit of the past, present, and future. The film will look at various projects, discussions, and decisions about Detroit’s future including:
• The events leading up to the housing foreclosure crisis – Detroit has more foreclosed homes than the next closest 16 cities combined with 100,000
• Examining the target neighbourhoods for relocation
• Different visual plans for the Future Detroit
• Exploring what Detroit can learn from LISC, HUD, both the state and city of New York and how they dealt with 100,000 vacant properties in NYC, part of what lead to Harlem’s revival
• The possible return of Devil’s Night arsons – Halloween arsons have been reduced from 810 in 1984 to 94 last year
• New Detroit Mayor David Bing’s action plan for the ailing city
• Hantz Farms planned World’s Largest Urban Farm to be set up in the urban core
• The Lonely Homes Tour – a caravan of sorts touring Detroit’s bargain basement priced mansions for sale
• The Detroit Land Bank and its attempt to stabilize the speculating occurring in a housing market where properties are changing hands for $1.
• The sale of the Silverdome to Canadians for $583,000 after costing $56 million to be built in 1985 – symbolic of how bad times have been in the state of Michigan.

We’ll interview many varied views of the city’s future, including:
• Time Magazine columnists Darrell Dawsey, Karen Dybis, and Steven Gray as they describe the magazine’s year long experiment in the city – namely purchasing a home in downtown Detroit and parachuting in 3 of their columnists to run The Detroit Blog while literally living and breathing the city for a year.
• Deborah L. Younger, executive director of the Detroit LISC (Local Initiatives Support Corporation), aiding in the turning around of Detroit’s housing crisis. Younger has also been appointed treasurer of the newly formed Detroit Land Bank Authority by Mayor Dave Bing.
• Newly elected Detroit Mayor David Bing and how he plans to cut Detroit’s government to a size proportionate to an 800,000 person city
• Richard Florida as he describes the flight of the creative class to Detroit
• Bill Strickland highlighting what Detroit can learn from Pittsburgh’s turnaround
• Chief of Police Warren Evans describing the challenges with enforcing an 800,000 person city set in 140 square miles of land with a 25% cut in police forces. Also how the police department works with one of the city’s only booming industries – private security.
• Jeff Bocan of the Huffington Post Blog who has relocated to Detroit and has started up a Venture Capitalist firm to invest in Health Care and Green Technologies in Detroit. He describes the opportunity now facing the city.
• Michigan State University sociologist Carl S. Taylor who spent six years in one of Detroit's most dangerous neighborhoods in the company of two of the most violent street gangs in America
• Six architecture students from the University of Detroit Mercy and their newly designed vision of Detroit

No comments:

Post a Comment